Although we are by no means “all caught up,” the MS backlog has shrunk considerably. Submissions that had been hanging in limbo for a considerable time have been read and dealt with (most, but not all, ending up as rejections).
At present, our MS flow is as follows (in alphabetical order of authors' names). We now have nine articles that are definitely in the MS bank to draw upon, and two that are probably in the bank.
• AOURAGH, Miriam . “The Internet, Palestinian Politics, and Mobilization: The Cyber-Intifada.”STATUS: Newly arrived. LKI is reading it. The author just defended a dissertation by this title at University of Amsterdam, and this reads very much like an extended dissertation abstract. It has potential, though. LKI will ask her to send a more developed, article quality piece.
• Atkinson, Keith. “The Pale of Settlement and Pale-stine.”STATUS: Arrived in early February. LKI has read. It is not for JPS. Kind letter of rejection to be sent shortly.
• BADRAN, Amneh. “The Politics and Roles of Liberal Israeli Protest Groups.”STATUS: Has been in the system for several months. Readers’ reviews were not very sanguine. LKI sent her a letter last week indicating we’d look at it again with revisions suggested by the readers, but no promise to publish. The topic is one that deserves more treatment in JPS.
• BASHKIN, Orit. “Reading Al-Sayyab in Israel.”STATUS: Arrived in mid-February. Assigned to Joseph and Rashid. Joseph is not sanguine about it. LKI likes it, but agrees with Joseph that it's rather sentimental.
• BEN BASSAT, Yuval. “Regional Aspects of Early Jewish-Arab Encounters at the End of the 19th Century.”STATUS: Arrived four weeks ago, solicited by Rashid (Mr. Ben Bassat was his student at Columbia). Very good article. Rashid and Joseph are to comment on it. No word from them yet, though LKI has read the article and rates it as a Must Publish item. It exceeds the word count, and suffers from some repetitiveness. [IN THE MS BANK]
• BOULBY, Marion. “The Islamic Movement inside the Green Line: Boundaries of Coexistence.”STATUS: This was in the system for a very long time with no decisions rendered. Readers’ reviews were very mixed. LKI read and commented on it last week, and sent the author a letter indicating that we’d like to see a rewrite according to readers’ comments and suggestions, but no promise to publish. This is an interesting topic that JPS needs to cover, but this paper, in its current form, is not yet "ready for prime-time." No word from the author yet.
• DEUTSCH and THOMPSON, “Secrets and Lies: The Persecution of Muhammad Salah.”STATUS: Excellent, unique, exciting and informative. But three times the usual word count and disorganized in terms of chronology. LB and LKI have read and corresponded with the authors. This came in via Sara Roy. Jamil Dakwar and Ali Abunimah are the external readers; LB and LKI think that Louise Cainkar should read it as well. A must publish, but will require considerable work. [IN THE MS BANK]
• FARAH, Randa. “Refugee Camps in the Palestinian and Sahrawi National Liberation Movements: A Comparative Perspective.”
Status: We sent her a letter asking for revisions and including readers’ reviews (four of them). She was initially discomfited, but on Thursday last week she sent in a revision that is excellent. Laleh Khalili read this second version yesterday (she was a reader the first time around) and raved about it. [IN THE MS BANK]
• FLORES, Alexander. “What Happens to Language: The New Antisemitism and Palestine.”STATUS: Came in at the end of December. Several readers, among them EC members, Editorial Staff and external readers responded vigorously. Consensus is that it is publishable and a very important topic, but only after extensive rewriting and rethinking. LKI sent the author a letter indicating same, along with readers’ comments, ten days ago. So far, no word from the author yet. [PROBABLY IN THE MS BANK]
• GRAY, Alice. “Water Development in Palestine since Oslo.”STATUS: This one has been in the system for about a year. No decisions made, though Alex Winder thought it was worth considering. Sherif El-Musa has it, but has yet to send in a review. [This one is a priority item for decision; it's been back-logged and neglected for far too long.]
• HANAFI, Sari. “Spacio-cide.”
STATUS: Nadia Abu El Haj vigorously rejected it. LKI thought it had some good points, particularly in comparison to another MS on related issues, but indicated that it would require a complete rewrite. Farah (see above) references a different incarnation of his thesis in her paper. LKI will send kind letter of rejection.
• HILAL, Jamil. “On the Making of Local Leadership in the West Bank.”STATUS: In the system for about five months. Salim Tamari is to send in a reader’s report today or tomorrow. This MS is an unabridged field report to an NGO. It is not, in LKI’s estimation, for JPS. But a standard rejection letter to Jamil is not acceptable. LKI is awaiting Salim’s advice on how to handle this.
• HOUT, Shafiq. Interview from 2006
STATUS: Rashid is reading it in French. [IN THE MS BANK]
• JOHNSON, Penny. “Public Spaces and Public Life.”
STATUS: In the system for about five months. It, like Jamil Hilal’s submission, is an unabridged version of a field report to an NGO. Full of rich ethnographic and interview data. LKI likes it very much, though it will require a complete rewrite. Amal Amirah also liked it and suggests we have her revise it for JPS. [PROBABLY IN THE MS BANK]
• MARSTON, Elsa. “Changing Portrayals of Palestinians in American Children’s Literature.”STATUS: in the system since MESA. LB indicates we will probably publish it. LKI has not yet read. No external readers yet. [PROBABLY IN THE MS BANK]
• MISHAL, Khalid. Interview (conducted by Mouin Rabbani a month ago. Final transcript to be sent in today (9 April). [IN THE MS BANK]
• SALEH, Mohsen. “Military Activities of the Muslim Brothers in Gaza, 1949-54”STATUS: Revised version submitted. Rashid and Khaled Hroub have given it a thumbs up. It requires extensive editing for language and style, which should bring the word count down. [IN THE MS BANK]
• SCHEMER, Yuval. “Salvage Cinema among Second Generation Mizrahim.”
STATUS: In the system for over a year. Received very mixed reader reviews. LKI now rereading it and considering how (or whether) to approach author for a rewrite.
• SHARKEY, Heather. “Presbyterian Church Politics in the Middle East, 1948-2008”STATUS: Solicited by Ussama Makdisi a month ago. Excellent paper, that covers some of the terrain we discussed as needing attention at the EC meeting. It is nearly 2000 words over the limit, though. Out to Joseph and Ussama for review. [IN THE MS BANK]
• VANRAALTEN, Judith. “Multiple Generations: Palestinian Displaced Populations.”STATUS: External reader review from Laleh Khalili just came in. She strongly recommends against publishing it. LKI feels it is too elementary and statistical for JPS. Kind letter to be sent.
• WAAGE, Hilde. “The Case of the Missing Oslo Files.”STATUS: With LB.
• WALKER, Summer. “Human Rights Reporting: The Case of HRW…”STATUS: In the system since late January. External reader (Jonathan Cook) strongly recommended publishing. LKI thinks it is publishable with updates and changed style; it reads a bit like a term paper. Still awaiting Jamil Dakwar’s legal analysis. [IN THE MS BANK]
• WELCHMANN, Lynn. “The Bedouin Judge, the Mufti, and the Chief Islamic Justice: Contesting Normative Discourses….”STATUS: It has gone through readings, comments, and one re-write. LB and LKI have done significant editing. More is needed. It will probably be ready for JPS#148. [IN THE MS BANK]
REJECTED MANUSCRIPTS (February to April)
• Amayreh
• Bernstein
• Cheema
• Gordon, N.
• Hanafi
• Hayden
• Johnson, R.
• Lewan
• Siklawi
• Shihade, M.
• Subhani
• Vassilupols
Monday, April 7, 2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)