Showing posts with label Unsolicited MS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Unsolicited MS. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

November Manuscript Traffic Flow Update

It was great to see all who attended the Editorial Committee meeting three weeks ago.

In the next few days we will be sending you the minutes of the meeting, follow-up reports, and (for those who could not attend) all of the materials that were distributed at the meeting. For those who have sent in their selections for the External Readers' data base, thank you so much!

We have received some new submissions since last week. They are listed below. If you would like to read any or all of these, let me know.

Braverman, Irus
"Planting the Promised Landscape: Zionism, Nature, and the Israeli Nation."
NOTE: This submission came in far above the word count; the author has been asked to resubmit a shorter version.

Norman, Julie
"The Activist and the Olive Tree: Nonviolent Resistance in the Second Intifada."
Word count: 7451

Radwan, Noha.
"Filastin bil-`ammiyyeh: Palestine in Egyptian Colloquial Poetry"
Word count: 6875

Renfro, Evan
"The Role of the Keffiyeh in Solidarity for Social Justice."
 Word count: 5772


Thanks to Beshara Doumani and Mayssun Sukarieh, we have received four articles and Mayssun's interview for the theme issue on Rosemary Sayigh's contributions to Palestine Studies and oral history.  

The authors of the articles received thus far are:

Allen, Diana 
"From peasants to revolutionaries to…? Economic subjectivity in post-revolution Shatila"

Humphries, Isabelle
"Negotiating Survival in the Homeland: Palestinian internal refugees in the Galilee"

Johnston, Penny
"What Rosemary Saw:  Reflections on Palestinian Women as Tellers of  the Palestinian Present"

Latif, Nadia
Kinship, Place and Belonging: Palestinian Camp Refugees in Lebanon


Those of you who have readers reports to send in, please try to do so before the end of the semester is upon us.

Thanks, and we hope to see many of you at MESA in two and a half weeks. JPS's booth is in a prime location in the exhibit hall.



Monday, September 29, 2008

September Manuscript Traffic Flow Report

The Fall Editorial Committee is just 11 days away.

Here is the latest traffic flow report. If you want to read any of the latest submissions, let me know. Also send me suggestions for external readers/reviewers.


LINE-UP FOR JPS # 149 (Fall 2008)

Deutsch and Thompson
Part II of "Secrets and Lies: The Persecution of Muhammad Salah"

Fischbach, Michael
“Palestinian Refugee Compensation and Israeli Counterclaims for Jewish Property in Arab Countries”

Hallaj, Muhammad
"Memoirs of 1948" (catchier title pending)

Shehadeh, Raja
Literary Essay (title pending)

Waage, Hilde
"The Missing Oslo Files"

Welchman, Lynn
"The Bedouin Judge, the Mufti, and the Chief Islamic Justice: Legal Pluralism in the West Bank and Gaza Strip"


ARTICLES IN PROGRESS

Farah, Randa
"Comparative Perspectives on Palestinian and Sahrawi Refugee Camps"
(Second version accepted. Catchier title will be provided and then sent to typesetter. Slated for #150 or #152)

Filiu, J-P
“French Diplomacy and the Palestinian Issue during Mitterand’s Administration.”
( Second version quite good. Accepted for publication after editing; slated for #150 or #152)

Robson, Mary
"The Greek Orthdox Controversy"
(Accepted. LK editing)

Sharkey, Heather
“The American Mission in Egypt, the Arab-Israeli Conflict, and Palestine: A Study of Presbyterian Church Politics in the Middle East, 1948-2008”
(Accepted for publication if revised. Revision expected by December)



THE FOLLOWING SUBMISSIONS ARRIVED DURING THE MONTH OF AUGUST:

Nasser, Maha
“Pressing for Return: Palestinian Citizens of Israel, al-Ittihad, and the Refugee Issue, 1948-59”
(Leila Farsakh and Rhoda Kanaaneh are reading it, as will LK)


Husseini, Rola
“Hizbullah and Hamas, Ties that Bind: Resistance as an Ideology”
(Leila Farsakh has read and commented, and is not particularly sanguine about it. LK has read and thinks it is publishable with some changes and improvements)

Samhouri, Mohammad
“Four Decades of Israeli-Palestinian Economic Relations, 1967-2007: What Have We Learned?”
(Raja Khalidi is reading it and will have comments in by October. Leila Farsakh has read and thinks it needs work before it can be published.)

Holt, Maria

“Identity under Siege: Palestinian Women and Memories of Violence in the Camps in Lebanon.”
(With Amal Amirah; no word yet.)

Pappe, Ilan.
“Vicissitudes of Israeli Historiography.”
(Rashid and LK have read it and agree it needs a rewrite)
Revised version to run in #150
(This is part of the MESA 2008 panel on 1948)

Masalha, Nur
“The Nakba, Oral History, and Collective Memory.”
(Rejected. Linda will write to him)

Davidson, Lawrence
Truman and the Establishment of Israel (part of MESA 1948 panel)
(RIK and LK have read and commented. Slated for # 150)
(This is part of the MESA 2008 panel on 1948)

Pallister, Polly
“Solidarity Now! The ‘Wall’ and evolving approaches to Israeli anti-occupation protest”
(It is with Amal Amirah. Looks more ‘activist-y’ than academic. Also 2000+ words over the word count limit)

Dr. Rida Blaik-Hourani
"Academic History Content for Palestinian Arabs in Israel: A Historical Review and Postcolonial Analysis"
word count: 12, 413
(LK has read; far too long and circuitous, apparently an unedited dissertation chapter. Kind letter to go out)

Lodewijk van Oord
Face lifting Palestine: Early western accounts of the Palestinian refugee problem
7,940 words (notes included)
(Looks good, although the title is weird; with Salim)

Weaver, Cassie
"Palestinians in Lebanon: Reconsidering the Impediments to the Realization of Civic Rights"
10,700 words
(She was Rosemary Sayigh’s Masters Student last year. Reads like a term paper and 3K over the word count)

MANUSCRIPTS THAT HAVE ARRIVED THIS MONTH (SEPTEMBER)

Shaindlinger, Noa
"Decolonizing History: Historical Representations of Jaffa in Palestine/Israel"
(Looks very good, though too long; going to Marc Levine and Dan Monterescu for reader review)
10,550 words


Clarno, Andy
Neo-liberal Apartheid: Israel and the Crisis of South African Liberation
6888 words
Looks like a “boiler plate” piece


Hughes, Matthew
The Meaning of Atrocity: The Villages of al-Bassa and Halhul, 1938-39
9269 words


PAPERS WE ARE AWAITING:

Amirah, Amal
Review essay about Memoirs of ’48.

Bashkin, Orit
"Reading As-Sayaab in Tel Aviv"

Grey, Alice
Water issues in Occupied Palestine

Lynk, Michael
Analysis of Israeli Settlements in Framework of IHL

Khalidi, Walid
1948 MESA Panel Paper (for #150)

Rogen, Eugene
1948 MESA Panel Paper (for #150)


Papers for the Special Issue Honoring Rosemary Sayigh for JPS # 151 (Spring 2009)

(Update to be presented at the Editorial Committee Meeting)

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Brief Update and Reminders

Undoubtedly, all of you are trying to squeeze in the last few weeks of fun, relaxation, and/or writing before the fall term begins. So, not wishing to overwhelm you,here is a brief update:

GOOD NEWS!

The new and improved IPS website is now on-line and completed. The URL has not changed, it remains http://www.palestine-studies.org . The 1948 mini-page, "1948: Sixty Years On" is now incorporated in the main website. Kudos to the IPS-Beirut office and Nadia Hijab for the launch!

MOST RECENTLY RECEIVED MANUSCRIPT:

NASSAR, Maha. "Pressing for Return: Palestinian Citizens of Israel, al-Ittihad, and the Refugee Issue, 1948-59."
WORD COUNT: 8,672.
STATUS: This one looks promising. Readers needed.

ARTICLES IN PLAY/UPDATES FROM LAST POSTING:

Alexander Flores sent in his revision of the "What's in a Name: The New Anti-Semitism" piece. It is problematic; he did not take many of the readers' comments and suggestions into consideration. Rashid is reading it.

Heather Sharkey has responded positively to the reader reviews of her article on "Presbyterian Church Politics in the Middle East," and will be sending us a revision in the Fall.

George Bisharat has just read and rejected S. Shamy's article, "Would 'Sorry' Repair my Loss." Amal Amireh need not read it, and LKI will send Shamy a letter today.

LKI has read M. Reme's submission on Palestinian refugees' civil rights in Lebanon and deemed it a "no go," so there is no need for readers' responses. LKI will send her a letter today.

The following authors have been writing in wanting to know the status of their articles. Readers should prioritize their comments on these.

• MUNAYYER, Yousef. “Arendtian Interpretations of Zionist Ideology: National Socialism in the Mirror.”
STATUS: Joseph and Nadia are reading it.
Word count: 4733

• ROBSON, Laura. "The Greek Orthodox Controversy in Mandate Palestine."
STATUS: She sent it to JPS on the advice of Alex Winder. She is a Ph.D. candidate in history at Yale. Ussama and Linda are reading it. Rashid found it good. 6400 words.


REMINDERS

* Looking Ahead to the Fall Editorial Committee Meeting:

At the last meeting in February, Rashid presented his "State of the Journal" overview. Below you will find the notes from the last meeting about this, in preparation for the next meeting, and to elicit responses from the EC:

The journal’s core concerns are justice in Palestine and policy decisions abroad that affect Palestine.

Rashid's main question was: How does the EC want to position the journal to set the agenda for thinking about Palestine and the attendant issues?

Beshara Doumani and Laurie King-Irani were assigned the task of producing an idea paper on this for circulation before/discussion at the next EC meeting. BD and LKI are to discuss the question of the journal’s intellectual agenda with a view toward readership.

* Your help is needed!

If you see documents, reports, statements, or interesting items from the International press about the question of Palestine, please forward them to us for the Documents and Press sections of the journal's back matter.

Friday, June 6, 2008

June 6th JPS Manuscript Traffic Flow and News

We have had some real meteorological excitement here in DC. A serious thunderstorm, part of a weather system that spawned tornados in the vicinity on Wednesday, took the flashing off of the office roof. Nadia's apartment and Linda's office suffered considerable water damage.

Issue No. 147 (Spring) should be out in the coming week. It features an interview with Khaled Mashal (conducted by Mouin Rabbani). Issue No. 148 (Summer) is moving along.

Here is the line up of articles for No. 148:
• DEUTSCH and THOMPSON. “Secrets and Lies: The Persecution of Muhammad Salah.” STATUS: LB is working on this and has consulted with one of the authors. We plan to run Part I in the upcoming issue (Summer #148).

• MISHAL, Khaled. Part II of interview conducted by Mouin Rabbani in Damascus in early March. Not in yet. Linda has been calling Mouin.

• SERHAN, Randa. "Palestinian Weddings in New Jersey."
STATUS: It is now typeset; this was slated for the Spring issue, but we have shifted it to the Summer issue.

• TARAKI, Lisa. "Enclave Metropolis."
STATUS: It is already typeset, and was slated for the current issue now in preparation, but we are shifting it to the Summer issue.

• WELCHMANN, Lynn. “The Bedouin Judge, the Mufti, and the Chief Islamic Justice: Contesting Normative Discourses….”
STATUS: IF THERE IS ROOM it may run in #148: LKI doing final editing before finalizing with Linda and author and sending to typesetter. This one has been in the system for two years.

Here is the latest manuscript flow update:

NEW MANUSCRIPTS:

• EBEID, Rifq. "Terrorism in Uniform."
STATUS: Just in today from a Law student. Well-written but too long. Out to Jamil Dakwar for review. If anyone else would like to see it, let us know.
WORDCOUNT: 11,335

• FILLIU. "French Diplomacy and the Palestine Issue during Mitterand's Presidency."
STATUS: Came in last week. LKI has sent it to Rashid. If anyone else would like to look at it, please let us know.
WORDCOUNT: 8071

• SAMY, Shahira. "Would 'Sorry' repair my loss? Why Palestinian refugees should seek an apology for their displacement."
STATUS: Came in ten days ago. A conflict resolution/reconciliation framework.
WORD COUNT: 7792


PROMISED ARTICLE
LYNK, Michael. "International Legal Analysis of Israeli Settlements." He has promised us an 8000 word piece by the end of the summer.


ARTICLES IN THE SYSTEM:
• BASHKIN, Orit. "Reading Al-Sayyab in Israel." LKI sent her Joseph's and Rashid's comments and request for revision. She will send us a new version by the end of the summer.

• BEN BASSAT, Yuval. “Regional Aspects of Early Jewish-Arab Encounters at the End of the 19th Century.”
STATUS: Arrived five weeks ago, solicited by Rashid (Mr. Ben Bassat was his student at Chicago). Very good article, with nice maps. Rashid feels the last part and conclusion need to be stronger. Awaiting Joseph’s comments.

• FARAH, Randa. “Refugee Camps in the Palestinian and Sahrawi National Liberation Movements: A Comparative Perspective.”
STATUS: Her revised version is very good. We can probably slot it for the Fall or Winter issue this year.

• FLORES, Alexander. “What Happens to Language: The New Antisemitism and Palestine.” [PROBABLY IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Came in at the end of December. Several readers, both EC members, Editorial Staff and external readers responded vigorously. Consensus is that it is publishable, but only after extensive rewriting and rethinking. LKI sent the author a letter indicating same, along with readers’ comments. On 10 April he responded that he has been absorbing the comments and will work on a revision for us. LKI will send him a reminder.

• GRAY, Alice. “Water Development in Palestine since Oslo.”
STATUS: LKI sent her readers’ reports and suggestions, she agreed to a rewrite and update and said it will be in to us by end of summer.

• JOHNSON, Penny. “Public Spaces and Public Life.”
STATUS: In the system for about five months. Amal Amirah and Salim Tamari have read it and given positive reviews and suggestions. LKI sent Penny the readers' reports and a letter asking for a revised version. No word from her yet. LKI will send her a reminder.

• MUNAYYER, Yousef. “Arendtian Interpretations of Zionist Ideology: National Socialism in the Mirror.”
STATUS: Joseph and Nadia are reading it.
Word count: 4733

• REME, Maria. "The Frozen Case: Civil Rights of Palestinian Refugees in Lebanon – Perceptions and Realities."
STATUS: Came in unsolicited in late April. Needs readers.

• ROBSON, Laura. "The Greek Orthodox Controversy in Mandate Palestine."
STATUS: She sent it to JPS on the advice of Alex Winder. She is a Ph.D. candidate in history at Yale. Ussama and Linda are reading it. 6400 words.

• SAFI, Khalid Muhammad. "The EU Policy towards the Islamic Resistance Movement." Unsolicited, from a professor at the Al Aqsa University in Gaza.
Word count: 9295. Sent to Khaled Hroub for review.

• SALEH, Mohsen. “Military Activities of the Muslim Brothers in Gaza, 1949-54” STATUS: Revised version submitted. Rashid and Khaled Hroub have given it a thumbs-up. LKI is doing an extensive substantive and stylistic edit. The author mentions more than 80 people without clearly specifying who they are or what their overall historical roles were. It's like the Gazan telephone directory of 1951! LKI has made an index of all individuals mentioned and is reading books and articles about the period to fill in some blanks, and has sent the list of names to the author for further clarification. No response yet.

• SCHEMER, Yuval. "Salvage Cinema among Second Generation Mizrahim."
STATUS: LKI doing a rewrite.

• SHARKEY, Heather. “Presbyterian Church Politics in the Middle East, 1948-200” STATUS: Solicited by Ussama Makdisi a month ago. Excellent paper, though nearly 2000 words over the limit. Out to Joseph and Ussama for review. Rashid feels it is two articles yoked together and requires a rewrite.

• WALKER, Summer. “Human Rights Reporting: The Case of HRW…”
STATUS: In the system since late January. External reader (Jonathan Cook) strongly recommended publishing. LKI thinks it is publishable with improvements and updates. Reads like a grad school term paper. George Bisharat has given it a thumbs up, conditioned on rewrite and update. LKI sent her comments and request for revision. She will send us a new, improved version in the Fall.


OTHER MANUSCRIPTS


These are manuscripts that are in various liminal categories
• HILAL, Jamil. “On the Making of Local Leadership in the West Bank.”
STATUS: In the system for about seven months. Salim Tamari is to send in a reader’s report. This MS is an unabridged field report to an NGO. It is not, in LKI’s estimation, for JPS. But a standard rejection letter to Jamil is not acceptable. LKI is awaiting Salim’s advice on how to handle this

• MARSTON, Elsa. “Changing Portrayals of Palestinians in American Children’s Literature.”
STATUS: in the system since MESA. With Linda. No external readers yet. Elsa wants to publish a version elsewhere, so it may be best to let this one go and remove it from the manuscript log.

• WAAGE, Hilde. “The Case of the Missing Oslo Files.”
STATUS: With Linda.

RECENTLY REJECTED MANUSCRIPTS

* KELMAN, Herbert. "Negotiating a Historical Compromise: New Opportunities for the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process."

Friday, May 23, 2008

May 23 Weekly Manuscript Traffic Flow Report

NEW MANUSCRIPTS:
• KELMAN, Herbert. "Negotiating a Historical Compromise: New Opportunities for the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process."
No readers yet.

• MUNAYYER, Yousef. “Arendtian Interpretations of Zionist Ideology: National Socialism in the Mirror.”
STATUS: Just came in yesterday, unsolicited, I believe. I think Joseph should read it. Not as good as the title promises… Joseph and Nadia are reading it.
Word count: 4733

• SAFI, Khalid Muhammad. "The EU Policy towards the Islamic Resistance Movement." Unsolicited, from a professor at the Al Aqsa University in Gaza.
Word count: 9295. No readers yet.

Below is the latest status report on current manuscripts, presented in order of readiness, urgency, or timeliness for publication.

• DEUTSCH and THOMPSON. “Secrets and Lies: The Persecution of Muhammad Salah.” STATUS: LB is working on this and has consulted with one of the authors. We plan to run Part I in the upcoming issue (Summer #148).

• MISHAL, Khaled. Part II of interview conducted by Mouin Rabbani in Damascus in early March. Not in yet.

• SERHAN, Randa. "Palestinian Weddings in New Jersey."
STATUS: It is going to the typesetter after the final edit; this was slated for the Spring issue, but we have shifted it to the Summer issue.

• TARAKI, Lisa. "Enclave Metropolis."
STATUS: It is already typeset, and was slated for the current issue now in preparation, but we are shifting it to the Summer issue.

• WELCHMANN, Lynn. “The Bedouin Judge, the Mufti, and the Chief Islamic Justice: Contesting Normative Discourses….”
STATUS: LKI doing final editing before finalizing with Linda and author and sending to typesetter. It could run in JPS#148 (Summer). This one has been in the system for over 2 years.

• FARAH, Randa. “Refugee Camps in the Palestinian and Sahrawi National Liberation Movements: A Comparative Perspective.”
STATUS: Her revised version is very good. We can probably slot it for the Summer or Fall issue this year. LKI has not yet started working on a final edit.

• BEN BASSAT, Yuval. “Regional Aspects of Early Jewish-Arab Encounters at the End of the 19th Century.”
STATUS: Arrived five weeks ago, solicited by Rashid (Mr. Ben Bassat was his student at Chicago). Very good article, with nice maps. Rashid feels the last part and conclusion need to be stronger. Awaiting Joseph’s comments.

• SALEH, Mohsen. “Military Activities of the Muslim Brothers in Gaza, 1949-54” STATUS: Revised version submitted. Rashid and Khaled Hroub have given it a thumbs-up. LKI is doing an extensive substantive and stylistic edit. The author mentions more than 80 people without clearly specifying who they are or what their overall historical roles were. It's like the Gazan telephone directory of 1951! LKI has made an index of all individuals mentioned and is reading books and articles about the period to fill in some blanks, and has sent the list of names to the author for further clarification. No response yet.

• SCHEMER, Yuval. "Salvage Cinema among Second Generation Mizrahim."
STATUS: LKI doing a rewrite.

• SHARKEY, Heather. “Presbyterian Church Politics in the Middle East, 1948-200” STATUS: Solicited by Ussama Makdisi a month ago. Excellent paper, though nearly 2000 words over the limit. Out to Joseph and Ussama for review. Rashid feels it is two articles yoked together and requires a rewrite.

• GRAY, Alice. “Water Development in Palestine since Oslo.”
STATUS: LKI sent her readers’ reports and suggestions, she agreed to a rewrite and update and said it will be in to us by end of summer.

• WALKER, Summer. “Human Rights Reporting: The Case of HRW…”
STATUS: In the system since late January. External reader (Jonathan Cook) strongly recommended publishing. LKI thinks it is publishable with improvements and updates. Reads like a grad school term paper. George Bisharat has given it a thumbs up, conditioned on rewrite and update. LKI will send the author readers’ comments today.

• ROBSON, Laura. "The Greek Orthodox Controversy in Mandate Palestine."
STATUS: She sent it to JPS on the advice of Alex Winder. She is a Ph.D. candidate in history at Yale. Ussama and Linda are reading it. 6400 words.

AWAITING REWRITES

• AOURAGH, Miriam. “The Internet, Palestinian Politics, and Mobilization: The Cyber-Intifada.”
STATUS: She will send in a revised version, an ethnography of internet "hacktivism" and cyber-attacks on activists.

• FLORES, Alexander. “What Happens to Language: The New Antisemitism and Palestine.” [PROBABLY IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Came in at the end of December. Several readers, both EC members, Editorial Staff and external readers responded vigorously. Consensus is that it is publishable, but only after extensive rewriting and rethinking. LKI sent the author a letter indicating same, along with readers’ comments. On 10 April he responded that he has been absorbing the comments and will work on a revision for us.

• JOHNSON, Penny. “Public Spaces and Public Life.” [PROBABLY IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: In the system for about five months. Amal Amirah and Salim Tamari have read it and given positive reviews and suggestions. LKI sent Penny the readers' reports and a letter asking for a revised version. No word from her yet.


OTHER MANUSCRIPTS IN THE SYSTEM


• BASHKIN, Orit. “Reading Al-Sayyab in Israel.”
STATUS: Arrived in mid-February. Assigned to Joseph and Rashid. Joseph is on the fence about it, as is LKI. A revised and tightened version could be part of an interesting theme issue, featuring, should we have publishable versions, Flores’ “New Anti-Semitism” and Schemer’s “Salvage Cinema among Second-Generation Mizrahim.” Rashid is going to give his comments shortly.

• HILAL, Jamil. “On the Making of Local Leadership in the West Bank.”
STATUS: In the system for about seven months. Salim Tamari is to send in a reader’s report. This MS is an unabridged field report to an NGO. It is not, in LKI’s estimation, for JPS. But a standard rejection letter to Jamil is not acceptable. LKI is awaiting Salim’s advice on how to handle this

• MARSTON, Elsa. “Changing Portrayals of Palestinians in American Children’s Literature.”
STATUS: in the system since MESA. With Linda. No external readers yet.

• REME, Maria. "The Frozen Case: Civil Rights of Palestinian Refugees in Lebanon – Perceptions and Realities."
STATUS: Came in unsolicited in late April. Needs readers.

• WAAGE, Hilde. “The Case of the Missing Oslo Files.”
STATUS: With Linda.

RECENTLY REJECTED MANUSCRIPTS

• DAHDAL, Andrew. “The applicability of International Law to the Middle East.”
STATUS: Came in unsolicited from a professor of law in Australia.
Word count: 9222 [George Bisharat has given it a clear ‘thumbs down’ so there is no need for other readers.]

• KLEIN, Menachem. "Hamas–Fatah Power Struggles."

• QAFISHEH, Mu'taz. "Origin of Citizenship and Migration in Palestine and Israel: Palestinian Nationality in the Period 1917-1925.

Monday, May 19, 2008

New Manuscripts Received; Readers Needed

Four new manuscripts have arrived over the last week. Would anyone like to volunteer to read one or more of them, and/or suggest outside readers? They are:

• DAHDAL, Andrew. “The applicability of International Law to the Middle East.”
STATUS: Came in unsolicited from a professor of law in Australia.
Word count: 9222

• KELMAN, Herbert. "Negotiating a Historical Compromise: New Opportunities for the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process."
Word count: 6438

• MUNAYYER, Yousef. “Arendtian Interpretations of Zionist Ideology: National Socialism in the Mirror.”
STATUS: Just came in yesterday, unsolicited, I believe. I think Joseph should read it. Not as good as the title promises…
Word count: 4733

• SAFI, Khalid Muhammad. "The EU Policy towards the Islamic Resistance Movement." Unsolicited, from a professor at the Al Aqsa University in Gaza.
Word count: 9295

For those of you who still have outstanding reviews, please get them in as soon as possible.

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Two New Submissions Received Today

Today, we received two new submission:

"The Frozen Case: Civil Rights of Palestinian Refugees in Lebanon – Perceptions and Realities." This article briefly presents the legal status and the living conditions of the Palestinians in refugee camps in Lebanon during the period of 1948-2005, and shows how the Lebanese government has not accepted responsibility for the refugees during most of this period. The article then suggests a variety of explanations for the situation, emphasizing that the fear of a permanent settlement of the refugees in Lebanon has created a belief system which in its consequence has banned Palestinian refugees’ civil rights, and has led to their isolation from the Lebanese society.


Hamas – Fatah Power Struggles

Since its foundation in 1987 Hamas has challenged the PLO and Fatah aiming to replace them in leading the Palestinian national movement. Their competition found expression in two parallel tracks: violent confrontations and political antagonism. The violent confrontations consist of bloody clashes between the followers of each movement and between policemen and security forces loyal to each side. These confrontations are frequent and have a variety of causes—protest demonstrations against non-payment of salaries, failure of the regime to keep promises, demonstrations in favor of or against the regime, or protest against violence by either side or counterattacks responding to such violence. They may also be brought on when the president, interior minister, or a local security force commander seeks to enforce laws or assert his powers.


If anyone would like to read and review one or both of these, or if you have names of potential external reviewers, please let me know.

On other fronts, Mouin Rabbani's interview with Khaled Mish`al is coming in now in segments. It will be a very timely and exciting addition to the next issue!

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Weekly Manuscript Traffic Flow Report

We have two new submissions in this week, one on "The Greek Orthodox Controversy in Mandate Palestine," and the other on "Origin of Citizenship and Migration in Palestine and Israel: Palestinian Nationality from 1917-1925." See below for more details. If you are interested in reading either or both of these, let me know. If you have external readers to suggest, send me their names and email contacts.

(It looks like an interesting history "theme issue" is shaping up, with Sharkey, Ben-Bassat, and the two new submissions today by Robson and Qafisheh.)

Since our Fall issue is slated to feature the papers that are in preparation for the MESA meetings (on the historiography of 1948), we now have a lot of good articles in our article bank. However, as noted last week, cultural anthropology, legal studies, and historical articles are well-represented, but some strong political science and international relations submissions would be very welcome. Please think of authors for such articles and send us their names and contact information.

Last but not least, please send in your top two preferred weekends for the Fall JPS Editorial Conference (the time parameters are between Sept 27-28 and Nov. 1-2.) As usual, this would mean arriving Friday by dinner time and being at the meeting all day Saturday.

Here is this week's status report, listed in alphabetical order of authors' names:

• AOURAGH, Miriam. “The Internet, Palestinian Politics, and Mobilization: The Cyber-Intifada.”
STATUS: She will send in a revised version, an ethnongraphy of internet "hacktivism" and cyber-attacks on activists.

• BADRAN, Amneh. “The Politics and Roles of Liberal Israeli Protest Groups.”
STATUS: Has been in the system for several months. Readers’ reviews were not very sanguine. LKI sent her a letter indicating we’d look at it again with revisions suggested by the readers, but no promise to publish. No word from her yet.

• BASHKIN, Orit. “Reading Al-Sayyab in Israel.”
STATUS: Arrived in mid-February. Assigned to Joseph and Rashid. Joseph is on the fence about it, as is LKI. A revised and tightened version could be part of an interesting theme issue, featuring, should we have publishable versions, Flores’ “New Anti-Semitism” and Schemer’s “Salvage Cinema among Second-Generation Mizrahim.”

• BEN BASSAT, Yuval. “Regional Aspects of Early Jewish-Arab Encounters at the End of the 19th Century.” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Arrived five weeks ago, solicited by Rashid (Mr. Ben Bassat was his student at Chicago). Very good article, with nice maps. Rashid and Joseph are to comment on it.

• BOULBY, Marion. “The Islamic Movement inside the Green Line: Boundaries of Coexistence.”
STATUS: This was in the system for a very long time with no decisions rendered. Readers’ reviews were very mixed. LKI sent the author a letter indicating that we’d like to see a rewrite according to readers’ comments and suggestions, but no promise to publish. No word from her yet.

• DEUTSCH and THOMPSON. “Secrets and Lies: The Persecution of Muhammad Salah.” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Excellent, unique, exciting and informative. But three times the usual word count and disorganized in terms of chronology. LB and LKI have read and corresponded with the authors. This came in via Sara Roy. Jamil Dakwar and Ali Abunimah are the external readers; LB and LKI think that perhaps Louise Cainkar should read it as well? A “must publish,” but will require considerable work.

• FARAH, Randa. “Refugee Camps in the Palestinian and Sahrawi National Liberation Movements: A Comparative Perspective.” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Her revised version is very good. We can probably slot it for the Summer or Fall issue this year.

• FLORES, Alexander. “What Happens to Language: The New Antisemitism and Palestine.” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Came in at the end of December. Several readers, both EC members, Editorial Staff and external readers responded vigorously. Consensus is that it is publishable, but only after extensive rewriting and rethinking. LKI sent the author a letter indicating same, along with readers’ comments. On 10 April he responded that he has been absorbing the comments and will work on a revision for us.

• GRAY, Alice. “Water Development in Palestine since Oslo.”
STATUS: This one has been in the system for about a year. No decisions made, though, Alex Winder thought it was worth considering. Sherif El-Musa has it, but has yet to send in a review. LKI will read it this week and ask El-Musa for his comments.

• HILAL, Jamil. “On the Making of Local Leadership in the West Bank.”
STATUS: In the system for about five months. Salim Tamari is to send in a reader’s report. This MS is an unabridged field report to an NGO. It is not, in LKI’s estimation, for JPS. But a standard rejection letter to Jamil is not acceptable. LKI is awaiting Salim’s advice on how to handle this.

• HOUT, Shafiq. Interview [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Rashid is reading it in French.

• JOHNSON, Penny. “Public Spaces and Public Life.” [PROBABLY IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: In the system for about five months. Amal Amirah and Salim Tamari have read it and given positive reviews and suggestions. LKI will send readers' reports and a letter today asking for a revised version.

• MARSTON, Elsa. “Changing Portrayals of Palestinians in American Children’s Literature.”
STATUS: in the system since MESA. LKI has not yet read. No external readers yet.

• MISHAL, Khaled. Interview, conducted by Mouin Rabbani in early March in Damascus. [SUPPoSED TO BE IN JPS # 147]
STATUS: The first part just came in today.

QAFISHEH, Mu'taz. "Origin of Citizenship and Migration in Palestine and Israel: Palestinian Nationality in the Period 1917-1925.
STATUS: Just arrived today, via author's contact with Sari Hanafi. About 800 words over the word count limit of 8000.

ROBSON, Laura. "The Greek Orthodox Controversy in Mandate Palestine."
STATUS: Just arrived yesterday. She sent it to JPS on the advice of Alex Winder. She is a Ph.D. candidate in History at Yale. 6400 words.

• SALEH, Mohsen. “Military Activities of the Muslim Brothers in Gaza, 1949-54” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Revised version submitted. Rashid and Khaled Hroub have given it a thumbs up. LKI is doing an extensive substantive and stylistic edit. The author mentions many people without clearly specifying who they are or what there overall historical roles were.

• SCHEMER, Yuval. “Salvage Cinema among Second Generation Mizrahim.” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: In the system for over a year. Got mixed reviews. LKI now rereading it and will restructure it. It could be an interesting piece for a cluster, alongside Orit Baskin and Alex Flores.

SERHAN, Randa. "Palestinian Weddings in New Jersey."
STATUS: It is just about ready to publish, and was slated for the current issue now in preparation, but we are shifting it to the Summer issue. [DEFINITELY IN THE ARTICLE BANK]

• SHARKEY, Heather. “Presbyterian Church Politics in the Middle East, 1948-200” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: Solicited by Ussama Makdisi a month ago. Excellent paper, though nearly 2000 words over the limit. Out to Joseph and Ussama for review.

• WAAGE, Hilde. “The Case of the Missing Oslo Files.”
STATUS: With LB.

• WALKER, Summer. “Human Rights Reporting: The Case of HRW…” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: In the system since late January. External reader (Jonathan Cook) strongly recommended publishing. LKI thinks it is publishable with improvements and updates. Reads like a grad school term paper. Still awaiting Jamil Dakwar’s legal analysis.

• WELCHMANN, Lynn. “The Bedouin Judge, the Mufti, and the Chief Islamic Justice: Contesting Normative Discourses….” [IN ARTICLE BANK]
STATUS: It has gone through readings, comments, and one re-write. LB and LKI have done significant editing. More is needed. It will probably run in JPS#148 (Summer).

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

New Manuscript Received: "Reading Al-Sayyab in Israel"

This one just came in yesterday, and looks interesting.

I've sent it to Joseph and Rashid to look at, but if anyone else would like to see it, just let me know.