Tuesday, December 9, 2008

End-of-Year Manuscript Traffic Flow Report

Greetings again from Washington. I hope all your semesters and projects for 2008 are coming to a pleasant and productive close.

Below is a comprehensive version of the usual JPS Manuscript Traffic Flow report, this time giving you an overview of what came in during the last ten months, what was rejected, and where things stand with articles in play and the submissions for the special theme issue on R. Sayigh’s work.

IMPORTANT REMINDER: If you have not yet sent me your choices for external peer reviewers (see the list of potential peer reviewers you received at the October EdComm meeting, or received by email if you were not able to attend the meeting), please be sure to do so before the year’s end.

Also, I collected the preferred telephone contact numbers of those who attended the October meeting. For those who were not here, please send me your preferred phone numbers soon.


MANUSCRIPTS RECEIVED DURING 4TH QUARTER OF 2008
(In reverse order of submission)


Erakat, Noura
“Litigating the Arab-Israeli Conflict: The Politicization of U.S. Federal Courtrooms.”
(Just came in yesterday. Too long and written in dense ‘legalese,” but it can be revised quickly for a JPS audience, and it also complements the recent 2-part Salah piece.)

Kark, Ruth and Seth J. Frantzman
“From Nomadism to Jewish Settlement: Bedouin, Abdul Hamid, British Land settlement and Zionism, The Baysan valley and sub-district 1831-1948.”
(First version was almost twice the acceptable word count. Authors were asked to submit a shorter version and did so in just a few days. With RIK)

Braverman, Irus
"Planting the Promised Landscape: Zionism, Nature, and the Israeli Nation."
(This submission came in far above the word count; the author was asked to resubmit a shorter version in late October. No response yet. LK will follow up with her.)

Muhaarab, Mahmoud
المقالات الصهيونية المدسوسة في الصحف اللبنانية والسورية
(“Zionist articles planted in the Lebanese and Syrian Press during the 1936-39 Revolt”)
With RIK and JAM.

Lehn, Walter
“The Khaduri Agricultural School.”
(LB not sure we are really going to consider it; not yet assigned for reader review)

Norman, Julie
"The Activist and the Olive Tree: Nonviolent Resistance in the Second Intifada."
LK has read and finds promising. Out to Amal Amirah and Beshara Doumani for EC reader reviews.

Radwan, Noha.
"Filastin bil-`ammiyyeh: Palestine in Egyptian Colloquial Poetry."
(Joseph is reading it.)

Renfro, Evan
"The Role of the Keffiyeh in Solidarity for Social Justice."
(LK has read; it is not ready for prime time. Kind letter to go out.)

Shaindlinger, Noa
"Decolonizing History: Historical Representations of Jaffa in Palestine/Israel"
(Mark Levine’s recommendation was not to publish, as there was nothing really new and fresh here. Kind letter to go out)


Clarno, Andy
Neo-liberal Apartheid: Israel and the Crisis of South African Liberation
(LK has read and finds it problematic and logically flawed. Awaiting EC reader reviews.)


Hughes, Matthew
The Meaning of Atrocity: The Villages of al-Bassa and Halhul, 1938-39
(No one has yet read this; with RIK)

Samhouri, Mohammad
“Four Decades of Israeli-Palestinian Economic Relations, 1967-2007: What Have We Learned?”
(Raja Khalidi is reading it and will have comments in by October. Leila Farsakh has read and thinks it needs work before it can be published. LK has followed up with Raja, but he has not responded)

MANUSCRIPTS SUBMITTED DURING 2nd & 3rd QUARTERS OF 2008

Robson, Mary
"The Greek Orthdox Controversy"
(Accepted; EC members feel it should be published with revisions (UM, ST, RIK). Heather Sharkey was external reader. Awaiting LB’s comments before sending request for revisions to the author.)

Nasser, Maha
“Pressing for Return: Palestinian Citizens of Israel, al-Ittihad, and the Refugee Issue, 1948-59”
(Leila Farsakh, Rhoda Kanaaneh, and LK have read it and found it publishable. Nadim Rouhana is doing an external reader review, and will have his comments in by the second week in January)

Husseini, Rola
“Hizbullah and Hamas, Ties that Bind: Resistance as an Ideology”
(Leila Farsakh has read and commented, and is not particularly sanguine about it. LK has read and agrees with Leila. LK sent the author suggestions for revisions in early October so it can be sent out for external review. No word yet from the author.)

Abu-Dheir, Farid
“Hamas' Media Discourse in the Government”
(poorly written and twice the standard word count. Kind letter sent)

Holt, Maria
“Identity under Siege: Palestinian Women and Memories of Violence in the Camps in Lebanon.”
(Kind letter sent)

Pappe, Ilan.
“Vicissitudes of Israeli Historiography.”
(Rashid and LK have read it and agree it needs a rewrite)
Revised version to run in #152

Masalha, Nur
“The Nakba, Oral History, and Collective Memory.”
(Rejected. Linda will write to him)

Davidson, Lawrence
Truman and the Establishment of Israel (part of MESA 1948 panel)
(RIK and LK have read and commented. Slated for # 152)

Pallister, Polly
“Solidarity Now! The ‘Wall’ and evolving approaches to Israeli anti-occupation protest”
(It is with Amal Amirah. Looks more ‘activist-y’ than academic. Also 2000+ words over the word count limit. LK inclined to send kind letter, but wishes to hear EC members thoughts first)

Dr. Rida Blaik-Hourani
"Academic History Content for Palestinian Arabs in Israel: A Historical Review and Postcolonial Analysis"
(Far too long and circuitous, apparently an unedited dissertation chapter. Kind letter sent in September)

Lodewijk van Oord
Face lifting Palestine: Early western accounts of the Palestinian refugee problem
(LK finds publishable, with revisions, although the title is weird; with Salim)

Weaver, Cassie
"Palestinians in Lebanon: Reconsidering the Impediments to the Realization of Civic Rights"
(She was Rosemary Sayigh’s M.A. student last year. Reads like a term paper and is 3K over the word count. LK has sent a kind letter via Rosemary)

Talaykurt, M.
“Post-September 11 Dilemmas of the United States.”
(Boilerplate and poorly written. Rejected; kind letter sent)


MANUSCRIPTS SUBMITTED MORE THAN A YEAR AGO

Saleh, Mohsen
“Muslim Brotherhood in Gaza in late 1940s and early 1950s.”
(Accepted last year, requires rewriting, not simply editing.)

Schemer, Yaron
"Salvage Cinema Among Second Generation Mizrahim."
(LK must do a re-write)

ARTICLES IN LINE-UP FOR JPS#150 (Winter 2009)

Welchman, Lynn
"The Bedouin Judge, the Mufti, and the Chief Islamic Justice: Legal Pluralism in the West Bank and Gaza Strip."
(Already typeset)

Farah, Randa
"Comparative Perspectives on Palestinian and Sahrawi Refugee Camps"
Second version accepted. LK must write abstract and select pull-out quotes

Filiu, J-P
“French Diplomacy and the Palestinian Issue during Mitterand’s Administration.”
(Second version much improved. Accepted for publication after editing; LB is working on it and has met with Filiu to discuss it.)


ARTICLES IN THE PIPELINE FOR JPS # 152, 153, and beyond...

Bashkin, Orit
"Reading As-Sayaab in Tel Aviv". Second version received in November, and sent to Ella Shohat for external review. Ella will send in her comments by mid-January.

Ben Bassat, Yuval
“Regional Aspects of Early Jewish-Arab Encounters in Palestine at the End of the 19th Century.”
(Accepted; undergoing final editing by LB and author)

Sharkey, Heather
“The American Mission in Egypt, the Arab-Israeli Conflict, and Palestine: A Study of Presbyterian Church Politics in the Middle East, 1948-2008”
(Accepted for publication if revised. Revision expected by December)


R. SAYIGH THEME ISSUE

Allen, Diana
"From peasants to revolutionaries to…? Economic subjectivity in post-revolution Shatila"
(Excellent!)

Humphries, Isabelle
"Negotiating Survival in the Homeland: Palestinian internal refugees in the Galilee"
(If any of the papers must be dropped due to space limitations, this would be the prime candidate to leave out of this theme issue.)

Johnston, Penny
"What Rosemary Saw: Reflections on Palestinian Women as Tellers of the Palestinian Present"
(LK finds it quite good.)

Latif, Nadia
Kinship, Place and Belonging: Palestinian Camp Refugees in Lebanon
(LK has not yet read)

Latte-Abdullah, Stephanie
“Fragile Intimacies: Marriage, Love, and Emotions in Palestinian Refugee Camps in Jordan (1948-2001)”
(First version was exceedingly long; Mayssun and Beshara asked for a shorter version and author complied immediately.)

Peteet, Julie
“Rosemary Sayigh and the Field of Palestinian Studies.”
(LK has not yet read)

Sukkariyeh, Mayssun
Interview with Rosemary Sayigh
(Second version has been checked over by LB. Mayssun has done another revision.)

PAPERS WE ARE AWAITING:

Christison, Kathleen
TBA

Amirah, Amal
Review essay about Memoirs of ’48.

Lynk, Michael
Israeli settlements in International Humanitarian Law

El-Hout, Shafiq
Interview (to be translated from French to English)



REJECTED MANUSCRIPTS
(February to December 2008, In alphabetical order of author’s names.

Abu-Dheir, F.
Amayreh, K.
Atkinson, K.
Badran, A
Bernstein
Blaik-Hourani
Boulby, M
Cheema
Dahdahl, A.
Flores, A.
Gordon, N.
Hanafi, S.
Hayden, R.
Hilal, J.
Holt, M.
Johnson, R.
Kelman, H.
Klein, M
Lewan
Masalha, N.
Marston, E.
Munayyer
Qafisheh, M.
Reme, M.
Renfro, Evan
Safi, K.M.
Samy, S.
Schaindlinger, N.
Shihade, M.
Siklawi, R.
Subhani, O.
VanRaalten. J.
Vassilupoulis, C.
Weaver, C.

No comments: